Sign up for newsletter

Grisman, Hartford, Seeger

Retrograss – 1999 (Acoustic Disc)

Reviewed by Kevin Oliver

Subscribe to Country CD Reviews CD Reviews

CDs by Grisman, Hartford, Seeger

David Grisman, John Hartford and Mike Seeger have managed to preserve and protect a great deal of this country's traditional music, both in performance and on record. This trio record is a bit different, however. They took some familiar songs from the bluegrass, R&B and rock and roll canon and adapted them to an old-time style.

What sounds like a gimmick not unlike the kitschy Run C&W band ends up something more in the hands of these veteran musicians. "Hound Dawg," the Big Mama Thornton song made famous by Elvis Presley, is appropriately playful, but in a parlor style they credit to the 1920's group Charlie Poole and The North Carolina Ramblers. Bob Dylan's "Maggie's Farm," is turned into a banjo tune in the mode of one of Dylan's biggest influences, Dock Boggs. The Chuck Berry classic "Memphis" becomes more a jug band tune than an early rock and roll tune.

Those more radical reworkings are balanced out by some less revolutionary, but still intriguing versions of bluegrass tunes - Earl Scruggs, "Pine Hill Special," Jimmy Martin's "My Walking Shoes" and the omnipresent classic, "Uncle Pen." With these more traditional tunes included, what could have been a mere novelty record becomes a fascinating study in the mutability of musical genres from another era.