Sign up for newsletter
 

The Judge and Jury

The Legend Of Jim Collins – 2000 (Pizzle)

Reviewed by Michael Berick

Subscribe to Country CD Reviews CD Reviews

CDs by The Judge and Jury

It's easy to quip that the verdict still is out on The Judge & The Jury, but it's an accurate statement as well. This young Georgia band definitely has its shining moments on their debut. Frontman/songwriter Aaron Parrett pens some winning melodies, and the group well executes a relaxed country sound that mixes in elements of bluegrass, old-time and Texas music.

But overall the disc is a split decision. While the words and music come together marvelously on the outlaw-on-the-road tale "Texas," a similarly themed "El Cuchillo" just makes you recall more memorable tunes by Joe Ely and Robert Earl Keen. On the simply told "Caroline," Parrett achieves a moving sense of heartache and in "Acres Of Blame" he finds an affective blend of wit and sentiment; however, the wordplay in "Hog Wire And Pliers" only comes off like sub-John Prine material. Still, this entertaining album, at a hair over 37 minutes, creates a strong enough impression to mark this as a promising effort.